Just In
Community
Forum
More
for All Those Who Wander

9/9 c21 Toliveinafantasy
This was really incredible. The level of detail, the characters, everything. You have a gift!
11/18/2020 c19 2Rogue's Queen
This is such a good story! Please update soon.
Rogue's Queen xx
11/15/2020 c19 1DuckingCute
This is a very original plot and your descriptions are beautiful. I also loved your worldbuilding and how you add on to Tolkien's work.
5/26/2020 c18 Guest
Thank you for such an amazing story! Your plot is so wonderfully creative and unique- every update is very much appreciated!
5/25/2020 c18 Aiwepitye10
This story is amazing! Can't wait for more!
4/1/2020 c8 Tony Swiecicki
Great stuff...I'm really enjoying the story... so where do you sit on the Orcs v Goblins debate? Are they the same - as maybe Tolkien meant - or were they separate species as per the films?
3/27/2020 c17 Reading In Moonlight
You made a mistake in the author note at the end of the chapter, you wrote that the Avari became the Noldor and the Teleri, and I am quite sure you didn't mean to say that.

Anyway, great chapter. Gil-Galad does seem letal, I have to agree with Bereneth on that one. And I am glad that there will be some action in the next chapter, Lindon court was a bit too calm!
3/6/2020 c16 Reading In Moonlight
Oh, that's interesting! The end of the chapter left me completely giddy. We met Gil-Galad! And he is... Amazing xD

As for the rest, this goes with the rest of the story, with the idea that courts are very formal. I always imagined elves are much more free and lively than that, given the few Princes and Kings we see in LOTR and The Silmarillion, and since Imladris is the last place with Noldor during the third Age and their elves are far from formal, but I do enjoy your take of elven society. Grace and gracewho wouldn't want to know how to thrive in such a setting? But I am happy I don't have to, and I have the feeling that Aeris will prefer to dance around the custom or even change it rather than bow to it.

I am looking forward to the next chapter!
2/17/2020 c15 Reading In Moonlight
I like this chapter more than the previous one, allthough it is quite sad.

I look forward to the next update.
2/14/2020 c14 Candice
Don't worry about being busy, it is understanding ! I must admit myself that university has been taking all my time as of late. So reading this chapter was a most welcome respite. Thank you for taking some of your time to write this story !

Anyway, this chapter was well-written and full of emotions. I loved it even if it made me a bit sad.

Good job, I am looking forward to the next chapter !
2/8/2020 c14 ZippyZappy
My heart! It was bound to happen (Gimlith's demise) eventually but I'm so sad that she couldn't at least see the sea one more time. Alas! It's going to be interesting how they cope with her loss and a change in scenery in the coming chaptersit's a lot to handle for anyone. Thank you for posting this amazing story and I hope you have a nice day!
2/6/2020 c14 Reading In Moonlight
I had to go and read Athrabeth Finrod ah Andreth after reading your author noteand I loved it! I also read the part of Morgoth's Ring about the Customs of the Elves. Thanks to you, I know which book I next want to buy!

I didn't like this chapter as much as others, but I suppose it is because of what had to happen to move the story forward. I am looking forward to the next update!
1/21/2020 c13 Candice
Thank you for the update !
It was a great chapter full of emotions and well-written. I liked the Gondolin flashback and the festival. I wonder what is going to happen now that Glorfindel is leaving.

Looking forward to the next chapter !
1/21/2020 c13 Reading In Moonlight
I find this chapter very sad; sad, but also beautiful. Poor Glorfindel, who loves Aeris, but whom Aeris will not love back because she has too much respect for him... And the fall of Gondolin was very sad too.

As all other chapters, I like this one very much. Rossorieth is an interesting new character, but she didn't make a great impression on me with all her references to how Gil-Galad is oh-so-perfect and amazing, and how his opinion matters so much more than anyone else's. I love Gil-Galad, but she makes him seem like a very arrogant elf, and I doubt he is as similar to Galadriel as Rossorieth makes it look like? Or maybe I am wrong? I will see soo enough I suppose.
Anyway, I don't trust Rossorieth good intentions at all and don't like her for now, though that may simply be because she is so beautiful and keeps her emotions well-hidden. I look forward to learning more about her, I may change my mind, or be proven right!

Anyway. Have I already said that I love this story? Because I do. And I look forward to the next update, hoping that it will come soon!
1/20/2020 c12 Reading In Moonlight
I like this kind of self-insert xD I hope it means that Dinalagos will live a very long life! Dogs are great characters :D
23 Page 1 2 Next »

Twitter . Help . Sign Up . Cookies . Privacy . Terms of Service