AN = I have had this idea for a while now so I thought it was finally time to write a story about it. This is set when Sam and Freddie aren't dating, a very long time after iLove You. The endings, unlike my other stories, are optional. You can just read the main story and choose whether to read the end. The ending is also alternative, there isn't just one ending. Anyways, I have always thought about this idea a lot, so I hope you enjoy!

Alternate

When someone says, 'to get it over with', it sort of implies they mean 'to get it over with' but does that mean it was good or bad that they got it over with? One dork and one demon both agreed their first kiss together was just 'to get it over with' (their exact words) but that doesn't mean neither of them didn't enjoy it...

"It's not my fault you're a dork!" The blonde argued, while walking into the Shays' apartment with Carly and Freddie.

"Stop, both of you! I am sick of your constant arguing!" Carly yelled.

"I was just trying to make a point..." She muttered.

"Thank you, Carly! At least someone cares about me..." Freddie smiled, looking over at Sam.

"I didn't say I didn't care about you!"

"Yeah, you have. Like a hundred times!"

"Not another argument!" Carls mumbled, trying to ignore her friends. She went to the fridge and got out the squirty cream.

"I do care about you!"

"Prove it!"

"How on earth do I do that-Carly!?" Sam roared. The brunette was smarter than she looked, she went up to them both and squirted cream in their faces.

"Seriously?" Freddie whined, wiping some cream off his nose.

"Sorry, but this was the only way to stop you arguing..." She paused and narrowed her eyes as she watched the boy walk up the stairs, "Where are you going?"

"To wipe this stuff off my face!"

She rolled her eyes and turned back to the blonde. Samantha was stood there daydreaming and staring at the top of the stairs.

"Someone got a new little crush?"

"Me? Like the nub?"

"You did date last year..."

"Don't bring that up again... It was a waste of a month."

"Now where are you going?" Carly repeated, watching her friend run up the stairs.

"To check the dork is okay..."

"Only Sam and Freddie..." She laughed, spraying cream into her mouth and dropping herself onto the sofa.

Me and Sam don't argue all the time, Freddie thought to himself, But I know for a fact she doesn't care about me...

"Knock knock..." Sam said, entering the room.

"Oh, it's you..."

"Like seeing you always brightens up my day." She joked. She walked over to Freddie and stood there, looking into his eyes for a moment.

"I do care about you." She whispered.

"Can you find a way to prove it?"

"No, but-Wait, you still have some cream on your lips..." Before Freddie could stop her, she smashed her lips against his.

The kiss wasn't intense or horrible. The total opposite actually. It was gentle and soft. Freddie was shocked. Sam was shocked. Wait, why was Sam shocked?

I am showing Freddie Benson how I feel, Sam thought to herself, Finally after so long, I can prove I still love him. I can't believe I am still in love with a dork though...

After about two minutes, they had to break the kiss for the need of air.

"Well..."

"Well..."

"We never speak of this again..." Sam said. She let go of his hands and turned around to exit the room.

"Wait..." Freddie finally found his voice and he was ready to use it...

- Alternative Ending 1 -

"Look, F-Freddie. I-I'm sorry, okay?" Sam stuttered, turning around to the dork again.

"No, I'm sorry."

"What have you got to apologize for?"

"For letting you go."

She cracked a small smile. "So have I proved I care about you?"

He slowly nodded and gave her a weak smile back. "Hey, Sam?"

"Yeah?"

"I missed you..."

"Once a nub, always a nub..." Sam muttered, before giving Freddie another kiss.

- Alternative Ending 2 -

"Yeah, Freddie?" Sam said, looking back at the boy.

"You meant that?"

"Yeah." She paused and thought carefully about what she was saying, "Yeah. I did."

"Why didn't you say anything sooner?"

"I hate all that mushy stuff. You know that!"

"And, I also know I was a totally nub for letting us break up to begin with..."

"It wasn't just your fault. The feeling was mutual."

"Promise me one thing..."

"Yes?" She intwined their hands together once more.

"You won't ever let me lose you again..." He smiled, giving her another kiss...

- Alternative Ending 3 -

"No, Freddie. I really have to go..." Sam said, still not facing him.

"Please, Sam..."

"Bye..." A sad smile grew on her lips as she walked out the room and down the stairs.

"Sam... We have to talk about this!"

"Talk about what?"

"You know what!"

"I said to never speak of it again..."

"Too late..."

"Hey, guys. What's going on here then?" They turned around to see their brunette friend standing there.

"Nothing! Absolutely nothing!" Sam said quickly, before storming out of the apartment.

"Shall I go after her?" Carly asked Freddie.

"Maybe it's best not to..." He watched as the door shut fully. It felt like she had just walked out of his life for good...

AN = What ending did you read? Or did you read all three? Was it a happy ever after? If it wasn't, maybe it just wasn't meant to be. I specifically liked the squirty cream part. It is actually a reference to Carly putting cream on carrots back in iOmg. Anyways, hope you liked!