Clueless Carraway by Lbforev Nick asks Gastby for a space to write. Days pass and Gatsby asks for Nick to read what he has written but he has written a gay love story. Nick is clueless but it's adorable. Yes, I know I suck at summaries. It's cute if you don't like reading smut.
K+, English, Romance & Fantasy, words: 3k+, favs: 1, 12/14, [J. Gatsby, Nick C.] Jordan B.
All The Things I Could Have Done by Lbforev Courageous Nick AU where Nick admits his feelings for Gatsby early on. This leads to a very interesting relationship as the two figure each other out.
K+, English, Romance & Friendship, words: 2k+, favs: 1, 11/24, [J. Gatsby, Nick C.] Daisy B., Tom B.
The Great Gatsby II » by NuclearHydrargyrum Several years after the death of Jay Gatsby, Nick Carraway finds a mysterious necromancy book that has a spell with the potential to bring Gatsby back from the Shadow Realm. However, Nick is unaware of the negative consequences of using dark magic. It is up to Nick, Tom, and Gatsby to work together to save the world. Rated T for mild violence and mild language.
T, English, Parody & Adventure, chapters: 3, words: 2k+, 11/23, [Nick C., J. Gatsby, Tom B.] Daisy B.
One Day and It’ll be Okay » by Lbforev High school and modern AU of The Great Gatsby. Nick is new to New York and when he is partnered the first day with Jay Gatsby something was bound to happen. Then at a party when Jordan and Daisy kiss for a game of spin the bottle what happens the next morning when they realize what happened the previous night.
T, English, Romance & Parody, chapters: 12, words: 25k+, 11/17, [J. Gatsby, Nick C.] [Daisy B., Jordan B.]
Beautiful Fool by Aivioletlys Daisy wishes she were a beautiful fool, life would be easier if she was. But she is smart and beautiful and she will do what she must. The world is a cruel place for those who aren't beautiful little fools after all. Daisy does what she must to survive, she has a daughter to look after.
T, English, words: 1k+, 11/15
1 Daisy Chains » by Jackdawsonlove A series of moments from Daisy's point of view intertwined with Taylor Swift songs
K+, English, Romance & Drama, chapters: 10, words: 5k+, updated: 9/2 published: 9/1, Daisy B., J. Gatsby, Tom B.
America I'm putting my queer shoulder to the wheel by the ocean weekender 1922: Disaster, but at least Gatsby didn't die. 1923: An even bigger disaster, Nick doesn't want to go to Gatsby's 4th of July party and gets very drunk with Jordan in true mlm/wlw solidarity. He's dragged to the party anyway and confesses to a love Gatsby doesn't requite. How on earth is he going to get out of this one?
T, English, Romance & Angst, words: 5k+, favs: 1, 9/2, J. Gatsby, Jordan B., Nick C.
1 We Can't Run Anymore Jay by notjavert Nick confesses his love but life never gives us good timing
T, English, Romance & Tragedy, words: 1k+, 8/4, J. Gatsby, Nick C.
2 Her There by Lbforev This songfic is based on an AU where it is basically as if the events from the big fight and after haven't happened. This means Gatsby and Daisy continued to fool around even though Daisy is married to Tom. The song is Heather by Conan Gray
K+, English, Romance & Poetry, words: 1k+, 7/22, [J. Gatsby, Nick C.] Daisy B.
31Nicole Carraway » by crimsonsky132 One minor change can bear life and death to many, and perhaps Jay Gatsby outruns his treacherous fate. There are plenty of flowers in the garden, after all.
T, English, Tragedy & Romance, chapters: 8, words: 15k+, favs: 78, follows: 114, updated: 7/18 published: 3/2/2016, J. Gatsby, OC
A Whole New World Ft Nick Carraway by WilRei9650 What happens when Nick Carraway from The Great Gatsby is somehow teleported from the 1920s to the year 2020? How will he react to how the world has changed, both technologically and socially? Will he learn how to cope in this new world and what will happen to him in modern-day New York City? *WARNING* Gatsby Plot Spoilers, could be really big ones
K, English, Humor & Adventure, words: 2k+, favs: 2, 4/21, Nick C.
1 Something Only I Could Give You by diluted Nick's been working on a secret project and Jay is dying to know what it is.
K+, English, Romance & Humor, words: 1k+, favs: 6, follows: 1, 4/6, [J. Gatsby, Nick C.]
Found by diluted "I suppose…I suppose I was looking for something, all those years. Looking in the wrong place." (Based on the dialogue prompt "I knew I'd find you here" from a post by stefansalfatore on Tumblr.)
K, English, words: 290, favs: 3, 4/5, [J. Gatsby, Nick C.]
1 Pretty by diluted Now Jay (elegant, handsome, pretty Jay) probably thought Nick was…attracted to him. Which Nick was. Jay probably also thought Nick was a fool, which Nick also was, or at least felt like at the moment. (Inspired by the dialogue prompt "You have pretty hands" from a post by stefansalfatore on Tumblr.)
K+, English, Romance, words: 482, favs: 1, 4/4, [J. Gatsby, Nick C.]
Any Time Ever by diluted "I like your new place." "Jay, this is your house." (Inspired by the dialogue prompt "I like your new place" from a post by stefansalfatore on Tumblr.)
T, English, Romance, words: 447, favs: 4, follows: 1, 4/3, [J. Gatsby, Nick C.]
1 The Great Gatsby’s » by Lbforev A continuation of The Great Gatsby by F. Scott Fitzgerald with a rewritten Chapter 9 but the book didn't end there either. I apologize for any inaccuracies about the 1920s era Nick x Gatsby Fanfiction
T, English, Romance & Tragedy, chapters: 9, words: 21k+, favs: 1, 4/2, [J. Gatsby, Nick C.] M. Wolfsheim, OC
Moonlight Waltz by Gypsy of the Aether An AU where Gatsby didn't die after the incident at the pool. Feelings emerge in the moonlight that casts into Nick's dark home. Wrote this 3 years ago, roast it as you please. If you want me to continue, I might.
T, English, Romance & Tragedy, words: 2k+, favs: 2, follows: 1, 3/23, [J. Gatsby, Nick C.]
New Sight by FanasticalFREAK07 The sound of booming thunder and crackling lightning lit the world around her. As raindrops splattered across the windshield, making the lights that strewed across sky turn into swirls and lines across glass. The tires squealed and the sound of screaming greeted Daisy's ears. She closed her eyes as the car flipped over and spun through the air. (Daisy is replaced by someone new.)
T, English, Adventure & Drama, words: 273, favs: 2, follows: 4, 3/16, Daisy B., J. Gatsby, Tom B., OC
3Wallflower » by Hillary Streisand What if it wasn't Gatsby and Daisy that met before the war, but Nick and Jordan? Jordan is a young girl of 18 that is caught in the middle of her older and younger sister. However, one night, she meets a handsome soldier by the name of Nick Carraway who is stationed at Camp Taylor. What could conspire between the two before Nick heads off to war? Will they ever be reunited?
T, English, Romance & Angst, chapters: 7, words: 11k+, favs: 8, follows: 10, updated: 10/2/2019 published: 7/22/2018, Jordan B., Nick C., OC
Hidden Love by Starlight1231 If the Great Gatsby had a 10th chapter, what would it be about? There are thousands of ways that it could have ended, but this is my take on the chapter and how I thought that it should have ended. I hope you enjoy reading it because I had a ton of fun writing it!
K, English, Romance & Hurt/Comfort, words: 791, favs: 2, 9/3/2019
The Great Expectations of Gatsby » by faith heart 14 years after Gatsby's death, Nick takes in one of Gatsby's sisters and raises her as his own. She grows up to be a wonderful, charming woman who meets Pammy Buchanan, who like her mother is a belle, and is entangled in the hierarchy of old and new rich people. But Della just wants to get justice for her brother and revenge on those who ruined him.
T, English, Drama, chapters: 5, words: 5k+, favs: 5, follows: 3, updated: 9/2/2019 published: 6/29/2019, Daisy B., Nick C., Tom B., OC
A Friend by onasilverriver A drabble set sometime after Daisy chooses Tom over Gatsby. Nick and Jay have a talk. Natsby if you want it to be.
K, English, Friendship, words: 972, favs: 6, follows: 2, 7/11/2019, J. Gatsby, Nick C.
1 Gatsby is No Good by OwenHarpersGirl This is a story that I wrote for my English Class
K, English, words: 759, favs: 2, follows: 1, updated: 5/28/2019 published: 4/21/2012
2 Beautiful Little Fool by LeesaCrakon Nick would be a fool to think that Gatbsy could ever love him back. But what if he did?
T, English, Angst & Romance, words: 1k+, favs: 10, follows: 4, 5/24/2019, J. Gatsby, Nick C.
it's you it's me it's a dream by the ocean weekender For the tumblr prompt: What if Gatsby survives, but then Nick keeps having nightmares about him dying and one night it's so bad he can't help but run next door to check that Gatsby is still alive? Gatsby's alive. There's a moonlight boat ride. Somehow, this disaster gay and disaster bi still manage to declare their undying love for each other.
T, English, Romance & Friendship, words: 2k+, favs: 8, follows: 6, 5/23/2019, J. Gatsby, Nick C.